"I recently saw Spirited Away and I'm still trying to formulate an opinion of it. I think that I may be the only anime fan who does not like his latest offering. He has sacrificed cinematic excellence at the altar of fantastical imagery ... and somewhere along the way, he lost a coherent message. Is this the beginning of the triumph of flash over substance in an area where we all respect the director too much to admit it?"
yeah, thats what i felt when i saw kurosawa's dreams, i felt it was a let down from the guy who made ran, seven samurai, and kagamusha....
but as it happens i actually was in the mood for cinematic imagery, and felt it was a much better and more coherently organized than, say fantastic planet, where it was such cinematic fantastic imagery after a while it literally began to annoy me....sheer cinematic imagery is not necessarily flash over substance, and i suspect a lot of fans felt it was more in the nature of a smorgisborg...where if you wanted a child's fairy tale, it gave you that, and if you wanted happy endings it gave you that, if you wanted a miazaki themed warning about ecology it gave you that, and so forth....
what i got out of it was a sense this movie is a fairy tale in the original context...like the way the brothers grimm originally wrote them. as precautionary tales...for example, little red riding hood is a warning to kids to never fully trust appearances, and to be alert for wolves masquerading as grandmothers, so spirited away is like not all magical creatures are like the costumed clowns you see in disney world, but have rules, and motivations that fit within their own logical context of their own, and can be dangerous....
like a anti totaro, if you will.....