This is a tough question, in that "favorite" & "craptalk" in the same sentence make it hard to decide. I'm going to make the assumption (yes, yes, I know) that winning is a bad thing, for the sole reason that I believe "craptalk" trumps "favorite". Favorite, to me, implies you like it, but "craptalk" implies suckiness. So, with that in mind, the forum that "wins" is actually the loser, with positive points being a bad thing in my made up scoring system...
Hearsay/history score...
EFCB: 0 - I was around for all of it, sadly enough
Noobermeet (G3): 1 - I'm not sure when G3 came into existence. It's a bit of a Red-Headed-Stepchild as far as I can tell... it's there & all, & occasionally does... stuff... but no one likes to acknowledge its existence, even though it does good things... still, 1 point
Rec Room (Studios): 0 - just started
Fridge (Studios, defunct): 4 - saw a lot of it, but it was there when I arrived & was disbanded for sucking; never really posted in it or paid attention to it
Church of Despair/General Revelry (FWP, defunct): 0 - never heard of it, don't care, no points
Ye Dwarven Hammer (ye CoM): 0 - I was around for the start of it
TDD v1.0.3 Technical Bugs (TeamBG, defunct): -50 - hearsay from reliable sources indicates it was the epitome of suckitude, but I refuse to acknowledge it as a competitor - pretending it never happened seems preferable
"My experience" score...
TDD v1.0.3 Technical Bugs (TeamBG, defunct): 0 - no experience, but has already been disqualified based on my scoring system
Ye Dwarven Hammer (ye CoM): 10 - boring topics posted by people you would swear were teenagers but are surprised to find out they are 20-something-+ ; anything of any possible interest is locked immediately
Church of Despair/General Revelry (FWP, defunct): 0 - don't care, no points
Fridge (Studios, defunct): 2 - never really cared, was just interested in MOD's, occasionally skimmed a topic or two, bleh
Rec Room (Studios): -27 - so far: lame, lame, lame
Noobermeet (G3): 3 - an occasional interesting topic, but largely boring... Happy Birthday [insert random user here]!!!
EFCB: 15 - I really, no truly, don't find non-BG-related topics on a BG-MOD board interesting, but here there are enough self-righteous posts full of silly... ahem... blather... that I occasionally feel the absolute *need* to post something - can't really explain it - stupid, I know - I should, like, work on that, or something
And so, the "winner", by my arbitrary scoring system is... EFCB (15), trailed closely by Ye TeenyBopper Hammer (10), with Fridge (6) & Noobermeet (4) in the distance. EFCB: king of craptalk
- Imrahil